Keeping Your Ex Spouse from Being Administrator of Your Estate

In most situations, the last person you would want to give the authority to administer your estate would be a former spouse. In fact, to avoid such a contingency, it’s a fairly common practice for parties to a divorce to include language in the divorce decree prohibiting either from acting as administrator of the other’s estate. A ruling from the Albany Surrogate’s Court, however, has demonstrated the importance of careful estate planning to ensure that such a result does not ensue. Here’s what happened.

In the Matter of Walsh, Jr., the deceased had a child who had priority to serve as the administrator of his estate, but the child was still a minor. Because the child could not serve as administrator, the court needed to appoint a fiduciary. The decedent’s ex-wife, mother to the child, successfully petitioned the court to be the legal guardian of the child. Once she became the legal guardian, she also had authority and became the administrator of the estate.

In response to the appointment of the ex-wife as administrator of the estate, the deceased’s brother filed a motion with the court to remove her, citing the divorce decree, which specifically stated that neither party would serve as executor or administrator of the other’s estate. The court, however, ruled against the brother, concluding that the ex-wife was not serving personally and individually as administrator, but rather as guardian of the minor child.

The upshot of the decision? You need to be very careful when you designate who will act as your administrator, and you are best served to identify specific successor administrators, in the event your primary choice is unwilling or unable to serve.

At the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston, we have extensive experience representing individuals facing similar concerns. We can provide a thorough analysis of your estate planning and implement measures to ensure that your wishes are honored.

Contact the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston

At the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston, we focus our estate administration practice on estates subject to probate in Nassau County and Suffolk County on Long Island. Contact our office online or call us at 631-425-7299 to set up a free initial consultation.

What Happens If a Beneficiary is also a Witness to a Will?

Under New York law, a valid will must contain the signatures of two witnesses. There are no requirements regarding the capacity of the witnesses. The testator (person executing the will) must sign in the presence of the witnesses, but they need not sign in each other’s presence. There’s also nothing that prohibits you from having a family member as a witness to your will, but there can be consequences.

Under New York law, a witness who has also has an interest in the estate is known as an “interested witness.” The fact that the will was witnessed by an interested witness does not invalidate the will, but it will render any benefit to the interested witness in the will void. Accordingly, any conveyance of property to an interested witness under a will, even if it’s part of a residuary estate, will be ineffective and will be returned to the estate, to be divided among other beneficiaries.

The “interested witness” rule, however, can apply to more than just property received. Consider the facts in Matter of the Estate of Cynthia R. Wu. In that case, the deceased had a provision in her will that called for estate and inheritance taxes to be paid as debts of the estate, rather than by beneficiaries out of their pro rata share of the estate. The deceased’s brother, the named beneficiary of two life insurance policies owned by the decedent, had also been a witness to the decedent’s will. The court concluded that, because the brother was an interested witness, he was not entitled to the benefit of having the estate taxes paid out of the estate. Instead, the court ordered him to pay his pro rata share of the estate taxes out of the death benefit proceeds.

Contact the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston

At the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston, we focus our estate administration practice on estates subject to probate in Nassau County and Suffolk County on Long Island. Contact our office online or call us at 631-425-7299 to set up a free initial consultation.

“No Contest” Provision in Will May Be Contested

A will contest can be an expensive and time-consuming process. While the will contest is in process, beneficiaries will have no access to estate assets. Unfortunately, will contests can often be used to wrongfully gain leverage against other beneficiaries.  As a consequence, it’s not uncommon for a will to contain a “no contest” or “in terrorem” clause, which typically states that any beneficiary who unsuccessfully challenges the validity of a will automatically forfeits any bequest granted in the will.

That does not mean, however, that a potential estate beneficiary may not challenge the validity of a will. Under the provisions of the Surrogate Court Procedure Act (SPCA), an estate beneficiary has the right to engage in “preliminary discovery,” i.e., to gather initial evidence, to adequately assess whether a will may be successfully challenged. Among the various methods by which a beneficiary can gather evidence to evaluate the potential validity of the will are:

  • Production of written documents
  • Testimony of the attorney who prepared the will, as well as any witnesses who attested to the validity of the will
  • Testimony of named executors or proponents of the will, but only if there is a no contest provision in the will

Furthermore, if there is a no contest clause, the court may grant potential claimants the right to gather any information that may be relevant to the validity of the will. Such information may include evidence regarding the mental capacity of the person executing the will, as well as evidence regarding financial matters. For example, in Matter of Liebowitz, in a ruling issued in February, 2016, the court ruled that allowing beneficiaries to gather evidence from the deceased’s business manage would not invoke the provisions of the will’s no contest clause, provided the evidence was sought to establish or challenge the validity of the will.  Some discovery is allowed. The provision of “no contest” clause does not take effect in most jurisdictions until you file formal Verified Objections.

Successfully settling an estate can be an extremely complicated process, even when there’s no “no contest” provision. Don’t try to handle it on your own. Attorney Bonnie Lawston has the knowledge, skill, experience and resources to protect your interests.

Contact the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston

At the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston, we focus our estate administration practice on estates subject to probate in Nassau County and Suffolk County on Long Island. Contact our office online or call us at 631-425-7299 to set up a free initial consultation.

An Executor’s Fiduciary Duty to Determine Fair Market Value of Property

Under the estate laws in New York, a person named in a will as an executor has certain “fiduciary duties.” A fiduciary duty is essentially the requirement to act in the best interest of another party. The fiduciary duty owed by an executor is the duty to act in the best interests of the estate and all beneficiaries to the estate. The fiduciary duty imposed on an executor requires that the executor always put the interests of the estate above his or her own self interests.

In addition, though, an executor has a duty to find and manage the assets of the estate in the best interests of the estate and, ultimately, the beneficiaries. That typically includes taking “reasonable” steps to preserve or maximize the value of estate assets. A 2014 opinion in the Surrogate’s Court in Kings County addressed that specific issue.

In Matter of Mahler, 2009-1485/B, Richard Mahler was the named executor of the estate of Margaret Van Cortlandt Billmyer. Among the estate’s assets was real property, which Mahler contracted to sell to a personal acquaintance for the purchase price of $670,000. Three days after the closing on the sale of the property, the buyer, Basile, sold the property for $1.3 million.

Adelphi University, an heir to the estate, contested the accounting of the estate and the New York State Attorney General joined in the action, asking the court to find that Mahler had breached his duty to act in the best interests of the estate. The petitioners asked the court for $630,000 in damages—the difference between the sales price to Basile and Basile’s revenue three days later.

In response to the legal action filed against him, Mahler contended that the property was run-down and needed extensive repairs. Adelphi and the Attorney General’s office alleged, however, that Mahler had failed to obtain any comps (prices for comparable properties in the area) and that he had taken no action to determine the actual fair market value of the real estate.

When questioned by the court, Mahler could provide no explanation for the difference in value over the three day period. The court concluded that the petitioners had met their burden to show that Mahler had breached his fiduciary duty to exercise diligence and care when selling the property. In its opinion, in fact, the court found Mahler “utterly devoid” or the required care to be exercised by a fiduciary. The court concluded that a $630,000 surcharge assessed against Mahler was appropriate.

The opinion rendered by the Surrogate’s Court demonstrates the importance of seeking experienced legal counsel when you’ve been named executor or administrator of an estate. At the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston, we offer comprehensive counsel to executors, administrators and personal representatives, helping you avoid any potential fiduciary challenges.

Contact the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston

At the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston, we focus our estate administration practice on estates subject to probate in Nassau County and Suffolk County on Long Island. Contact our office online or call us at 631-425-7299 to set up a free initial consultation.  Our attorneys and staff can enforce the applicable laws of New York State and require the executor, administrator or trustee to maximize your inheritance and protect your rights.   Call us for a free consultation and deferred legal fees.

 

The Impact of Undue Influence on Wills and Property Transfers

One of the more common allegations in estate litigation is the assertion that someone exerted undue influence on a decedent, either causing the decedent to transfer property before death to that person or to change a will or trust the benefit of the undue influencer. One of the challenges, in these cases, is determining exactly what constitutes “undue influence.” Fortunately, in New York, the courts have addressed this issue, most famously in Matter of Ryan, 34 AD3d 212 (2006).

In Ryan, the court considered allegations of undue influence in the estate of a 92-year-old woman who died in early 1995. She had eight children living at the time of her death, and her last will and testament, executed in 1992, specifically excluded three of them from receiving any of the proceeds of her estate, valued at approximately $450,000. Instead, most of the estate was left to her other children, as well as the wife of her eldest son, Tomas. There were provisions in the 1992 will explaining why she had disinherited the three offspring—because they had initiated proceedings in California to remove Tomas as a co-fiduciary in the estate of the decedent’s brother-in-law. The 1992 will also had a handwritten note attached to it, stating the specific reasons for the disinheritance.

The three disinherited children objected to the probate of the will, saying its execution had been obtained by fraud and undue influence. The Surrogate Court denied that summary judgment, concluding that there were sufficient factual issues that a jury could consider to find the existence of undue influence. The appellate court disagreed.

According to the appellate court, the well-settled law in New York defines

“undue influence” as “mental coercion that led the testator to carry out the wishes of another, instead of his or her own wishes, because the testator was unable to refuse or too weak to resist.” (Matter of Burke)

The court also cited established law that requires both a showing of motive and opportunity to exert undue influence, as well as actual proof of undue influence. Circumstantial evidence may suffice, but it must be of a “substantial nature.”

According to the appellate court, the only basis for undue influence asserted in Ryan was that Tomas had such a relationship with his mother that she was always willing to “take his side in all disputes.” The court found that the decedent had such a relationship with his mother that predated the execution of any of her wills, and held that “gratitude, love, esteem or friendship which induces another to make testamentary dispositions of property cannot ordinarily be considered as arising from undue influence.”

The appellate court also found that:

  • There was no evidence that Tomas coerced his mother to do anything she didn’t want to do
  • There was evidence that Tomas was not aware of the existence of his mother’s wills and was not involved in their preparation or execution
  • There was no evidence that the decedent had any mental or physical condition that took away her ability to act on her own behalf

Contact the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston

At the Law Office of Bonnie Lawston, we focus our estate administration practice on estates subject to probate in Nassau County and Suffolk County on Long Island. Contact our office online  or call us at 631-425-7299 to set up a free initial consultation.

What to Do When a Loved One Dies

When a loved one dies, the emotions you experience can paralyze you, causing you to neglect to handle some of the most basic tasks. That can complicate matters significantly.
Here’s a checklist of the steps you need to take following the passing of a loved one:

Continue reading